The goal of this clinical trial is to learn if the online, simulated human Talk to Nathan About Prostate Cancer Screening decision aid (https://www.cdc.gov/prostate-cancer/talk-to-nathan/index.html) is effective in helping patients decide about prostate cancer screening. The main questions it aims to answer are: * Is using the Talk to Nathan About Prostate Cancer Screening decision aid effective in improving knowledge, overcoming health literacy barriers, and resolving decisional conflict compared to a standard decision aid or standard education materials? * What are the barriers and best practices for incorporating Talk to Nathan About Prostate Cancer Screening into the flow of primary care practice? Researchers will compare Talk to Nathan About Prostate Cancer Screening to a standard decision aid and to standard prostate cancer screening education materials to test the effectiveness of using Talk to Nathan About Prostate Cancer Screening. Participants will: * Use Talk to Nathan About Prostate Cancer Screening, use a standard decision aid, or use standard education materials about prostate cancer screening * Visit the primary care clinic for follow-up * Complete surveys as part of the clinical trial